Warriors Share Wiki:Create/Fanfiction Reviews and Suggestions

You can post your Fan-fiction on this page if you are a member of Project:Create. Other members will then give a rating using the grade scale and a small review, telling you what they liked, and some small ways on how to improve. For detailed critique of your work, then place a critique request on the Fanfiction Critiques page. When the story has not had a rating or comment for two weeks, it will be archived by the leader, Nightfern or the deputy, Leopardclaw. The page limit for fan-fiction posts is 15.

 The Grade Scale 

The grade scale begins with level zero (0) and ends at level ten (10). Zero is a story that shows no detail, incorrect grammar, spelling, and a boring plot. On WSW, our goal is to create colorful, descriptive fanfiction, so our stories should not have a grade of zero. Ten is a story that is superior to all others; it shows great detail, main idea, correct spelling, grammar, and an overall interesting plot. Five (5) is a story with potential that could use some work. Please, if a more than two (2) users grade a story more than 4, do not grade the story a zero. It's rude and may result in rebuke.

Archives here.

Clouds
Boring title is boring. :3 I've been working on this one, but there's a lot to cover and edit before I finish. Well, this is my main focus for a bit...so I want to bring out its best. 12:17, June 7, 2012 (UTC)

I give it a 9 1/2. It's very good, the characters are awesome, and the plot is great. I did see very small grammar mistakes, but other then that, it's very awesome :D. "That's a great idea!" "Well, not really."  14:53, June 10, 2012 (UTC)

Pffft, this is epic! I'm not finished it yet, but it get a 9 so far from me. <3 15:46, June 10, 2012 (UTC)